Selected Product:
no
picture
available
| The Black Hole War: My Battle with Stephen Hawking to Make the World Safe for Quantum Mechanics
Audio Cassette
Edition: Unabridged
Author: Susskind, Leonard
Publisher: Blackstone Audiobooks, Inc.
Release Date: August 2008
ISBN-10: 1433243679
ISBN-13: 9781433243677
List Price: $29.95
Average Customer Rating:
  | |
The Drunkard's Walk: How Randomness Rules Our Lives
ISBN-10: 0375424040
ISBN-13: 9780375424045
List Price:$24.95
A Student's Guide to Maxwell's Equations
ISBN-10: 0521701473
ISBN-13: 9780521701471
List Price:$28.99
Lightness of Being: Mass, Ether, and the Unification of Forces
ISBN-10: 0465003214
ISBN-13: 9780465003211
List Price:$26.95
The Complete Idiot's Guide to String Theory (Complete Idiot's Guide to)
ISBN-10: 1592577024
ISBN-13: 9781592577026
List Price:$16.95
An Introduction To Black Holes, Information And The String Theory Revolution: The Holographic Universe
ISBN-10: 9812561315
ISBN-13: 9789812561312
List Price:$17.00
|
To use our price comparison to get the cheapest price, please click on the "Find the Cheapest Price" button located above for The Black Hole War: My Battle with Stephen Hawking to Make the World Safe for Quantum Mechanics by Susskind, Leonard (ISBN-10: 1433243679, ISBN-13: 9781433243677).
At this time we have not yet written a review for The Black Hole War: My Battle with Stephen Hawking to Make the World Safe for Quantum Mechanics by Susskind, Leonard (ISBN-10: 1433243679, ISBN-13: 9781433243677). Please continue to keep checking back to this page as we are constantly adding reviews.
Summaries and Customer Reviews are supplied by Amazon.com
The inside account of the battle among Stephen Hawking, Leonard Susskind, and Gerardt Hooft over the true nature of black holeswith nothing less than our understanding of the entire universe at stake
Surprisingly well done
| Customer Rating: | | At first I was put off by the simplicity of the narative. Appeared and felt like a book on physics simply dumbed down -- but as I got further into the writing I found the writing style grew on me -- that this is an excellent writing on QM that is accessable to my nieces. L. Susskind is very thorough in his presentation, and after the first 100 pages or so, just paints an exciting picture that is very easy to follow, and, again, what is more impactful -- one simply WANTS to find out the "next step." OK -- Christmas gift for my nieces?? |
Black Holes
| Customer Rating:  | The book discusses a problem. According to Hawking, when an object falls down a black hole (BH), all information is lost. The problem is that this violates a principle of physics that information is never lost. The future cannot lose track of the past, for then the past would cease to exist, as the only meaning to the past is present observations and records. Susskind proposes a solution that took him a decade to resolve, and he discusses this in the book. The solution is the Holographic Principle, which is that all the information inside the 3-dimensional sphere of the BH resides on the 2-dimensional surface. An object falling down a BH never crosses the surface, and so the information is not lost. There is a "dual description" that does not refer to the inside.
Susskind makes heavy use of String Theory to establish the theory. Actually, one can arrive at the same conclusion without the use of String Theory or quantum mechanics, by simply focusing on basic principles of physics and general relativity (GR). According to GR, it takes an object forever to reach the BH, and so it never gets inside. We therefore cannot speak about the inside. Everything falling down a BH is eternally falling, and so the information is not lost. We cannot speak about the inside of the BH. This then is exactly Susskind's Holographic Principle, where all information is outside the BH.
Science, and in particular physics, is a collection of theories. A theory is a mathematical system along with observational and experimental agreement. If it is impossible in principle to perform an observation, the theory cannot speak about that situation. Science also includes guesses, research proposals, and hypotheses, not all of which are theories.
The confusion arises from the formal existence of a solution of GR that from the viewpoint of the falling object, the object crosses the event horizon in finite time. However, since it is impossible in principle to observe an object "entering" the BH, this formal solution does not exist in reality.
If we accept the argument that something that a falling observer (someone who cannot return nor communicate with the rest of the world) can observe is considered as a valid scientific observation, we then lose our ability to criticize people for believing that the dead go to Heaven. The dead person (one who cannot return nor communicate with the rest of the world) observes Heaven. We scientists must be very careful about our scientific reasoning, and not give others the opportunity to twist it to make it sound as if we support religion, as is, unfortunately, often the case.
In summary, the principle of objective observation implies that no object can enter a BH.
Another point is that the formal solution of GR from the viewpoint of the falling observer is not a valid solution of GR. This is due to the proven existence of a singularity at the center. Since the object reaches the singularity in finite time, this solution is not valid. If we insist on accepting this formal solution, we get into paradoxes, as is usually the case when one accepts formal invalid solutions.
According to the Holographic Principle, no future theory can discuss the inside of a BH.
I gave four stars. The book makes excellent reading. It helps clarify some aspects of String Theory. For this, I give it three stars. His points about information residing outside the BH give it another star. I do not give it five stars, as his main point about where the information is can be proven by understanding and applying basic principles of science. We scientists and teachers must never lose sight of basic principles.
Susskind makes the common error of defining a BH as a place where light cannot escape, implying that the idea of an inside of a BH is a meaningful concept, contradicting his own Holographic Principle. A correct definition of a BH is a mass so large that objects falling towards it are time-dilated and red-shifted out of existence.
Another error in the book is mentioning "the 3-dimensional space inside the BH". The geometry is very much non-Euclidean. Approaching a BH is geometrically similar to moving eternally outwards to the "end" of the universe. Speaking about the inside of a BH is geometrically similar to speaking about space outside the universe, i.e., not meaningful.
|
General Relativity Meets Quantum Mechanics
| Customer Rating: | | There is a lot of physics contained in this excellent book - modern, cutting-edge theoretical physics, that is. In 24 chapters and almost 450 pages, the author guides the reader through a maze of seemingly contradictory scientific arguments in order to resolve an important issue in the physics of black holes: whether information is forever lost to the universe after it has passed through a black hole's horizon. In essence, this involves a type of reconciliation between General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics. Although this involves very abstract and difficult-to-grasp concepts, the author, one of the main adversaries in this so-called black hole war, gently guides the reader through the various issues, starting from first principles right up to the cutting-edge subject at hand. The book is amply illustrated with many diagrams, drawings, figures and pictures in order to help further clarify the already-lucid descriptions that are given in the text. But, in addition to all the technical issues, the author has included much of the human element in this war. Interpersonal matters, many personal anecdotes, people's backgrounds and even the odd joke all contribute towards illustrating that the main theme of this book is a truly human endeavor: to understand a bit more about our universe. The writing style is clear, authoritative, friendly, even chatty and very engaging; the 450 pages fly by amazingly quickly. Although science buffs are likely to be those who will enjoy this book the most, the writing style is such that its contents are easily accessible to a much broader readership. |
The Black Hole War
| Customer Rating: | | On the whole good, but lacks clarity in parts. It tends to go from A to C without explaining what happened to B. |
A 'must' for not only science collections strong in physics and history, but for the general public library
| Customer Rating: | This insider's account of the theoretical battles between Stephen Hawking, the author and Gerald t'Hooft over the true nature of black holes, THE BLACK HOLE WAR, is a rare, fascinating examination of how scientists interact, how theories are created and challenged, and how the reputations of three of the world's greatest scientists - as well as the nature of physics itself - were affected by black hole research. THE BLACK HOLE WAR details the battle as much as the science, making it a 'must' for not only science collections strong in physics and history, but for the general public library.
Diane C. Donovan
California Bookwatch
|
|
