| Summaries and Customer Reviews are supplied by Amazon.com | Why do poets and artists so often disparage science in their work? For that matter, why does so much scientific literature compare poorly with, say, the phone book? After struggling with questions like these for years, biologist Richard Dawkins has taken a wide-ranging view of the subjects of meaning and beauty in Unweaving the Rainbow, a deeply humanistic examination of science, mysticism, and human nature. Notably strong-willed in a profession of bet-hedgers and wait-and-seers, Dawkins carries the reader along on a romp through the natural and cultural worlds, determined that "science, at its best, should leave room for poetry." Inspired by the frequently asked question, "Why do you bother getting up in the morning?" following publication of his book The Selfish Gene, Dawkins set out determined to show that understanding nature's mechanics need not sap one's zest for life. Alternately enlightening and maddening, Unweaving the Rainbow will appeal to all thoughtful readers, whether wild-eyed technophiles or grumpy, cabin-dwelling Luddites. Excoriations of newspaper astrology columns follow quotes from Blake and Shakespeare, which are sandwiched between sparkling, easy-to-follow discussions of probability, behavior, and evolution. In Dawkins's world (and, he hopes, in ours), science is poetry; he ends his journey by referring to his title's author and subject, maintaining that "A Keats and a Newton, listening to each other, might hear the galaxies sing." --Rob Lightner | Average Customer Rating: Another phenomenal book by Dawkins!! This is the fourth book I have read by Dawkins, the other three were The God Delusion, Climbing Mount Improbable, and The Greatest Show on Earth. Dawkins never seems to disappoint me. I love his writing style and his analogies are so easy to follow. Unweaving the Rainbow basically explains why science should be poetic and not some cold explanation of the world. I don't understand why people think this book is so hostile. He simply explains why things like paranormal science, the X-Files, psychics, and weird theories of evolution by fellow biologists like Gould damage science by giving an uneducated or improper view of scientific theories. Dawkins explains why he believes Gould is wrong (I tend to think Dawkins is correct) by discussing what is wrong with Goulds work. Dawkins simply states that species giving birth to other species is impossible and that it had to occur gradually. Makes sense to me. However, I digress. Overall, I found this book very informative and incredibly entertaining. Classic Dawkins. Highly recommended! Science or Magic? Richard Dawkins has the rare gift of turning science talk into poetry. While boasting a wide range of scientific knowledge, he inspires the reader into wonderment at how discoverable the universe just is. Anyone who is curious about all the mysteries of the universe -anyone with a mind capable of wondering- don't be satisfied with magical, less than logical explanations, he warns. Keep wondering. You might be surprised at how discoverable most things are with a little bit of scientific scrutiny. The Poetry of Atheism This book anticipates the storm that followed Richard Dawkins' best seller, "The God Delusion", which told us bluntly that there is no cosmic security, that there is some kind of a future in our DNA, that we are doomed to oblivion, so why not have good time while we're at it."
Apparently his idea of a good time is hope in Darwinism(his version, of course), a dose of random selection, a round or two of bottled atheism, and "let's all sing in the dark, because we are all doomed anyway.
He actually thinks that his Gospel of the Absence of God is something that will cheer people up. Who is he talking to, anyway? What kind of logic is behind the simple statement that "God does not exist because I say so"?
We have to begin by dissolving the imaginary iceberg that he has placed between human reason and the existence of God. He has not shown in any believeable, cogent and reasoned way that his version of Darwinian evolution disproves the existence of God. He has simply created a massive smokescreen asking people to believe on his word alone.
That is the crux of the question: can you demonstrate God's non-existence from evolutionary biology? In this book, written some years before "The God Delusion", but obviously anticipating it, he pulls out all stops, and there is one solid truth behind this wealth of words: atheists can be as moral, as upright, as in love with beauty and as concerned about their neighbors as anyone else. That is not the issue. The issue is: Does Darwinian evolution disprove the existence of God and the foundation of religion? The answer is No. This book anticipates "The God Delusion" by attempting to turn his roaring lion into a pussycat.
"The Selfish Gene" was a masterpiece of evolutionary biology - except for the End Notes, and this book is something of an extended End Note on his brand of evolutionary biology. There are golden threads throughout the book, as there are in the End Notes. But most are actually moral and ethical principles hanging on the thread of their own weight, with no intellectual or reasoned foundation, their only authority: Richard Dawkins himself. The best refutation I have found of the thesis of this book is Joyce Kilmer's "Rouge Bouquet". It is poetry and so is "Unweaving the Rainbow". But Richard Dawkins poetry does not blot out the stinging and sterile prose of "The GOd Delusion". If Richard Dawkins cannot make sense out of life, he certainly cannot make sense out of death. This book is a feeble attempt to do so. Inspiring Unweaving The Rainbow is not only a great science book for a casual reader, but it is also very inspiring because Dawkins' writing shows science and the natural world in a light that fills the reader with awe and wonder. Very well done and pleasant to read. What an author! What a book! I was first drawn to Dawkin through his book God Delusion. He was very good author there and he is a very good author here. You will be enlightened. | |