| | ||
| | | |
| |||
| |
|
| |
![]() | ![]() |
|
| | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
![]() Accounting & Finance Architecture Arts & Photography Business & Investing Business Management Computer Science Computers & Internet Education Engineering History Humanities Law Medicine Professional Science Reference Agricultural Sciences Social Sciences Archaeology Astronomy Behavioral Sciences Biological Sciences Chemistry Earth Sciences Education Essays & Commentary Evolution Experiments, Instruments & Measurement History & Philosophy Mathematics Medicine Nature & Ecology Physics Reference Technology Summaries and Customer Reviews are supplied by Amazon.com
Customer Reviews:Average Customer Rating: the story of Dr. Pepperberg and her African gray parrot. Alex & Me: How a Scientist and a Parrot Uncovered a Hidden World of Animal Intelligence--and Formed a Deep Bond in the Process Alex Was No Birdbrain This was a very interesting book about animal intelligence--or, more specifically, how an animal trained in language can let us know what they know. Alex was an African Grey parrot, selected at random by a pet store owner to protect against any bias on the part of the author who purchased him for study. Dr. Pepperberg, who received her doctorate in theoretical chemistry, was well-schooled in the scientific method when she made the crossover to studying animal communication. Alex became her star pupil for the next 30 years, before dying suddenly about 20 years before his time. During their long association, Alex learned more than 100 words and was able to use them to show that he was not just "parroting" back random utterances but was able to use them to distinguish conceptually among issues of color, shape, size, number, etc. Where the book becomes most interesting is when he starts using comments spontaneously to express his own thoughts, such as telling Pepperberg unprompted that she needed to "calm down" one day when she entered the lab in some agitation. The night before his death, he used such phrases with her as "you be good," "I love you," and "you'll be in tomorrow?" He even showed a mind of his own by one day deciding to give wrong answers to questions that he had answered perfectly up until then. In the end, Pepperberg estimated his intelligence to be comparable perhaps to that of a five-year-old child. A notable subplot to the book is Pepperberg's story of how difficult it was to convince universities and especially funding sources to support her work. When she started in the field, there was little appreciation for her type of research, and it took her years of working with Alex and other birds to turn skeptics into supporters. My only quibble about the book is that it reads more like a research study than the personal memoir the title would lead one to expect. (I was hoping for something more like Wesley the Owl.) Putting that aside, Pepperberg is to be lauded for her groundbreaking work and we are all in her debt for being able to understand our animal friends just that much more. Touching story I really liked this book, but that's about as far as it got. a meaningful lapse Near the end of her book Alex & Me, in a chapter called "What Alex Taught Me," the author Irene Pepperberg says: "Some people take this new understanding of animal minds as an argument for treating animals as if they had the same rights we give to ourselves. That is as wrong as ... " What is so remarkable about this quote is how jarring it is in a book that celebrates animal intelligence and the interconnectedness of all life. While THIS reviewer is not suggesting that we give the right to VOTE to grey parrots (if this reviewer had his way, not every HUMAN would have that sacred right), what is clear to me, from this absolutely grating and gratuitous paragraph (as though an evil gremlin had sneaked in this nasty disclaimer), is that whatever Alex HAD tried to teach Ms. Pepperberg, she did not learn. If this book has any meaning whatever, it is that animals DO (or ought to) have rights. Yes they can think It is a family joke that an aunt who had a dog would sometimes observe that "It can almost think". Irene Pepperberg has demonstrated with her beloved Alex, an african grey parrot, that not only can the bird with a brain the size of a shelled walnut communicate in human language but that it can understand what it is saying and can construct its own interpretations. Alex can certainly think. The example of Alex's description of an almond as a 'cork nut', combining the elements of the outer shell texture with the known edible content, demonstrates just how intelligent this bird is. As Irene says in several places throughout the book Alex demonstrates many traits that previous animal intelligence wisdom (read dogma) had said should be impossible. This book is a real treat from beginning to end. For those who don't want to believe that animal intelligence is a necessary precursor to the the evolution of human intelligence then this book is not for you. | | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ![]() | |
| |